How Old Town Lost Downtown to “New Town

How Old Town Lost Downtown to “New Town” | San Diego Uncovered

SAN DIEGO UNCOVERED

How Old Town Lost Downtown to “New Town”

Imagine owning property in the center of San Diego—and then watching the center of the entire city move away from you.

That's essentially what happened to Old Town in the late 1860s.

For decades, the settlement below Presidio Hill had been San Diego's commercial and civic center.

Then a 53-year-old businessman named Alonzo Erastus Horton arrived in 1867, looked at San Diego Bay and made one enormous real-estate bet:

The city was in the wrong place.

San Diego's Original Downtown Was Old Town

After the presidio era, homes and businesses developed around what we now call Old Town. Government, commerce and community life centered there.

But Old Town had a major geographic disadvantage.

It sat several miles from the best part of the harbor.

For a nineteenth-century city hoping to grow through shipping and trade, that mattered enormously.

Someone Had Already Tried Moving the City

Horton wasn't actually the first person to recognize the problem.

In 1850, William Heath Davis and partners attempted to establish a settlement closer to the bay.

The project failed and became remembered as “Davis's Folly.”

But the idea wasn't necessarily wrong.

It may simply have been early.

Then Alonzo Horton Arrived

Horton stepped off the steamer Pacific in San Diego on April 15, 1867.

Historical accounts say he was immediately impressed by the harbor and unimpressed by the location of the existing town.

He believed San Diego's future belonged beside the waterfront.

There was one problem: the city's trustees were no longer legally positioned to sell the pueblo lands he wanted.

So Horton Helped Pay for an Election

The San Diego History Center's timeline records one of the more extraordinary details of the story.

On the same day Horton arrived, he gave the county clerk $10 to help cover the cost of a new election for the Board of Trustees.

The election took place later that month.

With a functioning board again in place, city land could be auctioned.

Horton was ready.

The $265 Real-Estate Deal That Changed San Diego

On May 10, 1867, Horton purchased a huge tract of pueblo land near the bay.

Historical sources differ slightly on the exact acreage—some contemporary historical summaries say about 800 acres, while detailed studies describe roughly 960 acres acquired through Horton's early purchases.

But they agree on the number that makes the story unforgettable:

$265.

Horton had acquired the foundation for what would become modern downtown San Diego.

Buying Cheap Land Was the Easy Part

Land is only valuable if people want to live, work and invest there.

Horton understood that.

He didn't simply subdivide the property and wait.

He marketed it aggressively.

He sold lots, encouraged construction, promoted gardens and attractive buildings, donated or offered property to institutions and worked to create the infrastructure a functioning city required.

Horton's Secret Weapon Was the Harbor

Horton's thesis was simple: San Diego's economy would eventually revolve around the bay.

So he built toward it.

In 1869, he completed a large wharf at the foot of Fifth Avenue. The wharf gave ships a practical gateway into New Town and helped turn Fifth Avenue into an important commercial corridor.

Visitors arriving by sea no longer had to begin their San Diego experience miles away in Old Town.

Then He Built a City Around the Investment

New Town gained shops, houses, churches, a post office, theater and hotel.

The Horton House hotel opened in 1870 facing the plaza that would eventually carry Horton's name.

Horton wasn't just selling parcels.

He was creating reasons for his parcels to become more valuable.

In modern real-estate language, he was simultaneously developer, promoter, infrastructure investor and place-maker.

Old Town Fought Back

The shift wasn't universally welcomed.

Old Town residents had businesses, homes and investments tied to the existing civic center.

Moving government functions south threatened all of them.

The San Diego History Center documents complaints and political resistance as New Town gained influence.

This wasn't simply a debate about geography.

It was a fight over property values, political power and which group would benefit from San Diego's future growth.

The County Records Were the Tipping Point

Government offices were enormously important to a small nineteenth-century town.

In 1870, the County Board of Supervisors decided to relocate county records and government functions to New Town.

By 1871, the transfer was underway.

The San Diego Union also moved its operation from Old Town to New Town.

Once government, newspapers, businesses, hotels and transportation were clustering around the waterfront, Old Town's position became increasingly difficult to defend.

Then Old Town Burned

In 1872, a major fire destroyed a significant portion of Old Town's commercial area.

The San Diego History Center describes the disaster as effectively sealing Old Town's fate as the city's primary business center.

New Town had already been winning.

The fire accelerated the outcome.

The Name “New Town” Eventually Disappeared

This is one of the best ironies in the story.

Horton's development was the “new” San Diego.

Old Town became “old” largely because New Town succeeded.

Eventually, New Town didn't need the qualifier anymore.

It became simply San Diego—the downtown and waterfront city we recognize today.

Horton's Bet Was Really About Location

The story is often told as a tale of one visionary developer.

That's partly true, but it can oversimplify what happened.

Horton benefited from public land sales, government decisions, civic allies, infrastructure investment and a broader economic shift toward the waterfront.

He didn't single-handedly create modern San Diego.

What he did exceptionally well was recognize where growth was likely to happen—and then position himself directly in its path.

A $265 Purchase—and Thousands in Profit

A San Diego History Center study notes that Horton paid roughly 27 cents per acre for his initial tract and later made thousands reselling strategically located parcels.

The numbers are dramatic, but the larger lesson isn't “buy cheap land.”

It's that infrastructure can completely rewrite real-estate geography.

A wharf, government offices, hotels, transportation and commercial activity moved the perceived center of San Diego several miles south.

Old Town Didn't Disappear. Its Role Changed.

Old Town lost its status as San Diego's commercial downtown, but it survived as something different.

Today, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park preserves and interprets the early Mexican and American periods of the city.

Ironically, losing the race to become modern downtown eventually helped Old Town become one of San Diego's most recognizable historic districts.

The Real-Estate Decision That Redrew San Diego

Stand at Fifth Avenue and Broadway today and it's difficult to imagine that the city's center was once miles away.

Skyscrapers, hotels, restaurants, offices and neighborhoods now occupy the land around Horton's nineteenth-century gamble.

His central insight was remarkably straightforward:

A growing port city should grow toward its port.

San Diego agreed.

And Old Town became Old Town.

San Diego Uncovered

San Diego Uncovered explores the forgotten decisions, strange events, remarkable people and real-estate bets that shaped America's Finest City.

Sometimes a city's future is decided by politics.

Sometimes by geography.

And sometimes by somebody willing to spend $265 because he thinks everyone else is standing in the wrong place.

Explore More of San Diego

Nancy's Vacation Rentals has been helping guests experience San Diego for more than 25 years. We love sharing not only the beaches and attractions, but also the stories behind the neighborhoods that make San Diego unique.

Browse Nancy's San Diego Vacation Rentals