San Diego Built a Lighthouse So High the Fog Hid It

San Diego Built a Lighthouse So High the Fog Hid It | San Diego Uncovered

SAN DIEGO UNCOVERED

San Diego Built a Lighthouse So High the Fog Hid It

When the federal government chose a site for San Diego's lighthouse in the 1850s, the top of Point Loma looked almost perfect.

It stood hundreds of feet above the entrance to San Diego Bay. On a clear night, a light placed there could be seen far out at sea.

There was just one problem.

The lighthouse was so high that ships could sometimes sail beneath the clouds while the beacon disappeared inside them.

For 36 years, San Diego operated one of the highest lighthouse lights in the United States—until officials finally moved the light down the hill.

A Lighthouse for America's New Pacific Coast

California had only recently become a state when the federal government began planning a chain of lighthouses along the Pacific Coast.

Congress authorized eight West Coast lighthouses in 1852. San Diego, with its important harbor near the nation's southwestern boundary, was an obvious location.

Point Loma offered a commanding position overlooking both the Pacific Ocean and the entrance to San Diego Bay.

The Site Looked Perfect

The lighthouse grounds sit about 422 feet above sea level.

The tower raised the Fresnel lens even higher—approximately 462 feet above the water, according to the National Park Service.

From an engineering perspective, the logic seemed obvious: higher light, longer sightline.

Under ideal conditions, the National Park Service calculates a theoretical visibility approaching 31 miles for an observer about 30 feet above the water.

The Light Was Lit in 1855

The Old Point Loma Lighthouse began guiding ships on November 15, 1855.

Its third-order Fresnel lens concentrated light from an oil lamp into a powerful beam.

For most of its operating life, the beacon displayed a fixed white light visible around the horizon.

On clear nights, it worked impressively.

Then the Marine Layer Rolled In

San Diegans know the phenomenon today: low coastal clouds can blanket Point Loma while conditions near sea level remain relatively clear.

That was disastrous for a lighthouse perched on top of the peninsula.

The National Park Service says it became apparent not long after the lighthouse entered service that its elevation was its undoing.

Fog and low clouds repeatedly obscured the beacon.

The Ships Were Below the Light

That's what makes the story so counterintuitive.

A lighthouse is supposed to put its light where mariners can see it.

At Point Loma, engineers had maximized geographic visibility without fully accounting for San Diego's coastal weather.

A ship could be traveling through relatively clear air near the ocean while the lighthouse itself was hidden in a cloud layer hundreds of feet overhead.

The lighthouse hadn't been built too low.

It had effectively been built too high.

Life Up There Wasn't Easy Either

The lighthouse was also remarkably isolated.

National Park Service educational materials describe town as roughly 10 miles away—an all-day horseback trip in the nineteenth century.

Fresh water was another persistent problem.

The lighthouse family collected rainwater and even moisture from fog, eventually using a catchment basin and cistern completed in 1883.

Ironically, the same fog that made the lighthouse less useful helped provide water to the people living there.

Robert Israel Kept the Light for 18 Years

The final keeper at the old lighthouse was Robert Israel.

He and his family lived on Point Loma for years, maintaining the lamp, lens, buildings and grounds in an isolated environment.

His wife, Maria Arcadia Israel, maintained a garden, made raisins and hot peppers, entertained visitors and created decorative seashell frames—two of which the National Park Service says remain in the lighthouse today.

San Diego Finally Moved the Lighthouse

Eventually the problem could no longer be ignored.

A new Point Loma Light Station was constructed much closer to the ocean.

On March 23, 1891, the old lighthouse was extinguished and the new light began operating near the tip of Point Loma.

The National Park Service specifically identifies the old lighthouse's recurring fog and cloud problem as the reason for the move.

The Solution Was Almost Comically Simple

The original lighthouse had been placed hundreds of feet above the water.

The replacement was moved dramatically lower.

The National Register documentation describes the new light as being erected near the tip of Point Loma at an elevation of about 30 feet.

Instead of trying to shine over the marine layer, the new beacon could shine underneath much of it.

The Old Lighthouse Nearly Disappeared

After its closure, the old lighthouse was boarded up and abandoned.

Outbuildings vanished. Vandals removed pieces of the structure.

In 1913, according to the National Park Service, the commanding officer at Fort Rosecrans even recommended that the lighthouse be demolished.

Instead, the site became part of Cabrillo National Monument and eventually one of San Diego's best-known historic landmarks.

It Even Served During World War II

The lighthouse's story didn't end with navigation.

During World War II, the U.S. Army took control of the site, painted the old lighthouse in camouflage colors and used it as a signal station.

After the war, the property returned to the National Park Service, which restored the lighthouse to evoke its nineteenth-century appearance.

The Beacon Came Back for One Night

On November 15, 1955—the lighthouse's 100th anniversary—the tower was illuminated again.

This time the light came from electricity rather than whale oil.

It wasn't used for navigation. It was a commemorative gesture.

For one evening, the lighthouse that fog had defeated shone over San Diego again.

Was Building It There a Mistake?

It's tempting to laugh at the decision.

But that's too easy.

The site made sense based on one crucial variable: line of sight.

The higher the light, the farther away it could theoretically be seen.

The failure came from another variable—local atmospheric conditions.

The Point Loma lighthouse is a perfect example of how a technically logical solution can fail when engineers don't fully account for the environment in which it must operate.

The Mistake Became the Landmark

There's a wonderful irony to the story.

The lighthouse that replaced it still serves the maritime landscape near the water, but the obsolete lighthouse on top of the hill became the famous one.

Today visitors to Cabrillo National Monument walk through the restored keeper's residence, climb into the tower and look out over one of the most spectacular views in San Diego.

The very elevation that made the lighthouse unreliable is one of the reasons the site is so memorable today.

San Diego Uncovered

San Diego Uncovered explores the strange decisions, forgotten places, remarkable people and unexpected stories behind America's Finest City.

The Old Point Loma Lighthouse was built high so sailors could see it.

San Diego's fog had another idea.

Explore San Diego With Nancy's

Nancy's Vacation Rentals has been helping guests experience San Diego for more than 25 years. We love sharing the stories behind the landmarks, neighborhoods and coastline our guests come here to explore.

Browse Nancy's San Diego Vacation Rentals

Sources & Further Reading

• National Park Service — Old Point Loma Lighthouse Grounds
• National Park Service — The Lighthouses of Cabrillo National Monument
• National Park Service — Visiting the Old Point Loma Lighthouse
• National Park Service — New Point Loma Lighthouse
• City of San Diego Digital Archives — Old Point Loma Lighthouse
• National Park Service — Maria Arcadia Israel